SM
| First Half starts. | ||
| 2' | Hand ball by Kyle Duncan - New York Red Bulls | |
| 4' | Fouled by Frankie Amaya - New York Red Bulls | |
| 4' | Matt Miazga - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 7' | Fouled by Obinna Nwobodo - FC Cincinnati | |
| 7' | Luquinhas - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in attack. | |
| 9' | Brandon Vazquez - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 9' | Fouled by Andrés Reyes - New York Red Bulls | |
| 9' | Fouled by Frankie Amaya - New York Red Bulls | |
| 9' | Junior Moreno - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 11' | Fouled by Tom Barlow - New York Red Bulls | |
| 11' | Ian Murphy - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 13' | Fouled by Luciano Acosta - FC Cincinnati | |
| 13' | Kyle Duncan - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 17' | Fouled by Tom Barlow - New York Red Bulls | |
| 17' | Yerson Mosquera - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in attack. | |
| 18' | Carlos Coronel - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 18' | Fouled by Yerson Mosquera - FC Cincinnati | |
| 19' | Brandon Vazquez - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 19' | Fouled by Sean Nealis - New York Red Bulls | |
| 20' | Fouled by Frankie Amaya - New York Red Bulls | |
| 20' | Santiago Arias - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 21' | Missed chance. Elias Manoel - New York Red Bulls - shot with right foot from outside the box goes high. | |
| 22' | Corner - FC Cincinnati. Conceded by Andrés Reyes. | |
| 23' | Missed chance. Dominique Badji - FC Cincinnati - shot with the head from the right side of the six yard box missed to the left. Assist - Álvaro Barreal with a cross after corner. | |
| 24' | Andrés Reyes - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 24' | Fouled by Dominique Badji - FC Cincinnati | |
| 25' | Hand ball by Andrés Reyes - New York Red Bulls | |
| 25' | New attacking attempt. Dominique Badji - FC Cincinnati - shot with left foot from the left side of the box is saved in the left corner. Assist - Luciano Acosta with a through ball. | |
| 26' | Daniel Edelman - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 26' | Fouled by Luciano Acosta - FC Cincinnati | |
| 27' | Fouled by Álvaro Barreal - FC Cincinnati | |
| 27' | Kyle Duncan - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick on the right wing. | |
| 30' | Hand ball by John Tolkin - New York Red Bulls | |
| 31' | Fouled by Elias Manoel - New York Red Bulls | |
| 31' | Ian Murphy - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 32' | Delay in match - injury Dominique Badji - FC Cincinnati | |
| 34' | Delay over. They are ready to continue. | |
| 34' | Brandon Vazquez - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in attack. | |
| 34' | Fouled by Dylan Nealis - New York Red Bulls | |
| 34' | Substitution - FC Cincinnati. Aaron Boupendza for Dominique Badji - injury. | |
| 37' | Corner - FC Cincinnati. Conceded by Sean Nealis. | |
| 38' | New attacking attempt. Brandon Vazquez - FC Cincinnati - shot with the head from few metres is saved by goalkeeper in the centre of the goal. Assist - Luciano Acosta with a cross. | |
| 38' | Corner - FC Cincinnati. Conceded by Carlos Coronel. | |
| 39' | Fouled by Santiago Arias - FC Cincinnati | |
| 39' | Luquinhas - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick on the right wing. | |
| 39' | Santiago Arias - FC Cincinnati - receive yellow card for a foul. | |
| 41' | Fouled by Tom Barlow - New York Red Bulls | |
| 41' | Yerson Mosquera - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 41' | Tom Barlow - New York Red Bulls - receive yellow card for a foul. | |
| 41' | Delay in match - injury Yerson Mosquera - FC Cincinnati | |
| 43' | Delay over. They are ready to continue. | |
| 43' | New attacking attempt. Álvaro Barreal - FC Cincinnati - shot with left foot from the left side of the box is saved by goalkeeper in the centre of the goal. Assist - Junior Moreno. | |
| 44' | Fouled by Junior Moreno - FC Cincinnati | |
| 44' | Luquinhas - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 45' | Shot blocked. Frankie Amaya - New York Red Bulls - shot with right foot from the centre of the box is blocked. | |
| 45' | Goal! New York Red Bulls 1, FC Cincinnati 0. Tom Barlow - New York Red Bulls - shot with right foot from the centre of the box to the centre of the goal. | |
| 45+2' | New attacking attempt. Kyle Duncan - New York Red Bulls - shot with right foot from the right side of the box is saved by goalkeeper in the centre of the goal. Assist - Luquinhas. | |
| 45+2' | Fouled by Kyle Duncan - New York Red Bulls | |
| 45+2' | Obinna Nwobodo - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 45+3' | Offside - New York Red Bulls. Luquinhas with a pass, however Tom Barlow is in offside. | |
| 45+4' | Missed chance. Aaron Boupendza - FC Cincinnati - shot with left foot from more than 40 yards on the right wing missed to the left. Assist - Luciano Acosta with a head. | |
| 45+6' | Shot blocked. Frankie Amaya - New York Red Bulls - shot with right foot from outside the box is blocked. | |
| 45+6' | Corner - New York Red Bulls. Conceded by Matt Miazga. | |
| 45+8' | Shot blocked. Dylan Nealis - New York Red Bulls - shot with right foot from the centre of the box is blocked. Assist - Sean Nealis. | |
| 45+9' | First Half ended - New York Red Bulls 1, FC Cincinnati 0. | |
| 45' | Second Half starts New York Red Bulls 1, FC Cincinnati 0. | |
| 46' | Corner - New York Red Bulls. Conceded by Ian Murphy. | |
| 47' | Missed chance. Kyle Duncan - New York Red Bulls - shot with right foot from outside the box is high and wide to the right after corner. | |
| 50' | Corner - New York Red Bulls. Conceded by Álvaro Barreal. | |
| 51' | Shot blocked. Dylan Nealis - New York Red Bulls - header inside of six yard box - left side is blocked. Assist - John Tolkin with a cross. | |
| 51' | Shot blocked. John Tolkin - New York Red Bulls - shot with right foot from the right side of the box is blocked. | |
| 51' | Corner - New York Red Bulls. Conceded by Obinna Nwobodo. | |
| 52' | New attacking attempt. Dylan Nealis - New York Red Bulls - shot with the head from the centre of the box is saved in the left corner. Assist - John Tolkin with a cross. | |
| 53' | Fouled by Andrés Reyes - New York Red Bulls | |
| 53' | Santiago Arias - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 54' | Delay in match - injury Andrés Reyes - New York Red Bulls | |
| 55' | Delay over. They are ready to continue. | |
| 55' | Andrés Reyes - New York Red Bulls - receive yellow card for a foul. | |
| 56' | Fouled by Brandon Vazquez - FC Cincinnati | |
| 56' | Frankie Amaya - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 57' | Fouled by Obinna Nwobodo - FC Cincinnati | |
| 57' | Luquinhas - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in attack. | |
| 58' | Shot blocked. John Tolkin - New York Red Bulls - shot with left foot from outside the box is blocked. | |
| 60' | Shot blocked. Aaron Boupendza - FC Cincinnati - shot with left foot from the centre of the box is blocked. Assist - Obinna Nwobodo. | |
| 61' | Corner - FC Cincinnati. Conceded by Dylan Nealis. | |
| 61' | Corner - FC Cincinnati. Conceded by Sean Nealis. | |
| 62' | Shot blocked. Santiago Arias - FC Cincinnati - shot with left foot from the centre of the box is blocked. | |
| 62' | Shot blocked. Santiago Arias - FC Cincinnati - shot with right foot from the right side of the box is blocked. Assist - Álvaro Barreal. | |
| 62' | Corner - FC Cincinnati. Conceded by Frankie Amaya. | |
| 63' | Corner - FC Cincinnati. Conceded by John Tolkin. | |
| 64' | Missed chance. John Tolkin - New York Red Bulls - shot with left foot from outside the box is high and wide to the right. Assist - Daniel Edelman. | |
| 65' | Delay in match - injury Obinna Nwobodo - FC Cincinnati | |
| 67' | Delay over. They are ready to continue. | |
| 68' | Missed chance. Aaron Boupendza - FC Cincinnati - shot with the head from the centre of the box missed. Assist - Álvaro Barreal with a cross. | |
| 69' | Dylan Nealis - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 69' | Fouled by Brandon Vazquez - FC Cincinnati | |
| 69' | Substitution - FC Cincinnati. Yuya Kubo for Obinna Nwobodo - injury. | |
| 70' | Daniel Edelman - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in attack. | |
| 70' | Fouled by Brandon Vazquez - FC Cincinnati | |
| 71' | Fouled by Yuya Kubo - FC Cincinnati | |
| 71' | Luquinhas - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in attack. | |
| 75' | Fouled by Yerson Mosquera - FC Cincinnati | |
| 75' | Luquinhas - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick on the left wing. | |
| 75' | Yerson Mosquera - FC Cincinnati - receive yellow card for a foul. | |
| 75' | Goal! New York Red Bulls 1, FC Cincinnati 1. Aaron Boupendza - FC Cincinnati - shot with left foot from the left side of the box to the right corner. Assist - Luciano Acosta following a fast break. | |
| 77' | Fouled by Luciano Acosta - FC Cincinnati | |
| 77' | Kyle Duncan - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in attack. | |
| 78' | Missed chance. Luquinhas - New York Red Bulls - shot with right foot from the right side of the box missed to the left. Assist - Frankie Amaya with a through ball . | |
| 79' | Fouled by Kyle Duncan - New York Red Bulls | |
| 79' | Luciano Acosta - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 82' | Corner - FC Cincinnati. Conceded by John Tolkin. | |
| 82' | Shot blocked. Yerson Mosquera - FC Cincinnati - shot with the head from the centre of the box is blocked. Assist - Luciano Acosta with a cross. | |
| 85' | Substitution - New York Red Bulls. Serge Ngoma for Tom Barlow. | |
| 85' | Substitution - New York Red Bulls. Peter Stroud for Daniel Edelman. | |
| 86' | Fouled by Elias Manoel - New York Red Bulls | |
| 86' | Yerson Mosquera - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 90' | New attacking attempt. Álvaro Barreal - FC Cincinnati - shot with left foot from the centre of the box is saved in the left corner. Assist - Luciano Acosta. | |
| 90' | Corner - FC Cincinnati. Conceded by Carlos Coronel. | |
| 90+1' | Missed chance. Brandon Vazquez - FC Cincinnati - shot with left foot from the left side of the box missed to the left. Assist - Luciano Acosta with a through ball. | |
| 90+2' | Substitution - New York Red Bulls. Cameron Harper for Kyle Duncan. | |
| 90+2' | Substitution - New York Red Bulls. Omir Fernandez for Luquinhas. | |
| 90+3' | Shot blocked. John Tolkin - New York Red Bulls - shot with left foot from outside the box is blocked. | |
| 90+3' | Corner - New York Red Bulls. Conceded by Santiago Arias. | |
| 90+4' | Missed chance. Sean Nealis - New York Red Bulls - shot with the head from the centre of the box missed. Assist - Dylan Nealis. | |
| 90+5' | Aaron Boupendza - FC Cincinnati - won a free kick in attack. | |
| 90+5' | Fouled by Sean Nealis - New York Red Bulls | |
| 90+7' | Corner - FC Cincinnati. Conceded by Carlos Coronel. | |
| 90+7' | Substitution - FC Cincinnati. Sergio Santos for Ian Murphy. | |
| 90+7' | Carlos Coronel - New York Red Bulls - won a free kick in defence. | |
| 90+7' | Fouled by Sergio Santos - FC Cincinnati | |
| 90+8' | GOAL OVERTURNED BY VAR: Sergio Santos - FC Cincinnati - scores but the goal is ruled out after a VAR review. | |
| 90+9' | VAR Decision: No Goal New York Red Bulls 1-1 FC Cincinnati. | |
| 90+9' | Second Half ended - New York Red Bulls 1, FC Cincinnati 1. | |
| 90+9' | Matt Miazga - FC Cincinnati - receive yellow card. | |
| 90' | Penalty Shootout begins New York Red Bulls 1, FC Cincinnati 1. | |
| 91' | Goal! New York Red Bulls 1, FC Cincinnati 1 - 1 Luciano Acosta - FC Cincinnati - converts the penalty with a shot with right foot to the left corner. | |
| 92' | Goal! New York Red Bulls 1 - 1 - , FC Cincinnati 1 - 1 Omir Fernandez - New York Red Bulls - converts the penalty with a shot with right foot to the left corner. | |
| 93' | Goal! New York Red Bulls 1 - 1 - , FC Cincinnati 1 - 2 Yuya Kubo - FC Cincinnati - converts the penalty with a shot with right foot to the left corner. | |
| 94' | Goal! New York Red Bulls 1 - 2 - , FC Cincinnati 1 - 2 Frankie Amaya - New York Red Bulls - converts the penalty with a shot with right foot to the right corner. | |
| 95' | Penalty saved. Santiago Arias - FC Cincinnati - shot with right foot saved in the right corner. | |
| 95' | Goal! New York Red Bulls 1 - 3 - , FC Cincinnati 1 - 2 Sean Nealis - New York Red Bulls - converts the penalty with a shot with right foot to the right corner. | |
| 96' | Goal! New York Red Bulls 1 - 3 - , FC Cincinnati 1 - 3 Brandon Vazquez - FC Cincinnati - converts the penalty with a shot with right foot to the left corner. | |
| 97' | Goal! New York Red Bulls 1 - 4 - , FC Cincinnati 1 - 3 Cameron Harper - New York Red Bulls - converts the penalty with a shot with right foot to the high centre of the goal. | |
| 98' | Goal! New York Red Bulls 1 - 4 - , FC Cincinnati 1 - 4 Álvaro Barreal - FC Cincinnati - converts the penalty with a shot with left foot to the high centre of the goal. | |
| 98' | Penalty missed! Still New York Red Bulls 1 - 4 - , FC Cincinnati 1 - 4 John Tolkin - New York Red Bulls - hits the right post with a shot with left foot. | |
| 99' | Goal! New York Red Bulls 1 - 4 - , FC Cincinnati 1 - 5 Matt Miazga - FC Cincinnati - converts the penalty with a shot with right foot to the left corner. | |
| 99' | Matt Miazga - FC Cincinnati - receive yellow card for excessive celebration. | |
| 100' | Goal! New York Red Bulls 1 - 5 - , FC Cincinnati 1 - 5 Dylan Nealis - New York Red Bulls - converts the penalty with a shot with right foot to the right corner. | |
| 101' | Goal! New York Red Bulls 1 - 5 - , FC Cincinnati 1 - 6 Aaron Boupendza - FC Cincinnati - converts the penalty with a shot with left foot to the left corner. | |
| 102' | Goal! New York Red Bulls 1 - 6 - , FC Cincinnati 1 - 6 Elias Manoel - New York Red Bulls - converts the penalty with a shot with right foot to the top left corner. | |
| 102' | Goal! New York Red Bulls 1 - 6 - , FC Cincinnati 1 - 7 Sergio Santos - FC Cincinnati - converts the penalty with a shot with left foot to the right corner. | |
| 103' | Goal! New York Red Bulls 1 - 7 - , FC Cincinnati 1 - 7 Peter Stroud - New York Red Bulls - converts the penalty with a shot with right foot to the right corner. | |
| 104' | Penalty saved. Yerson Mosquera - FC Cincinnati - shot with right foot saved in the right corner. | |
| 105' | Penalty missed. Serge Ngoma - New York Red Bulls - shot with right foot goes high. | |
| 105' | Goal! New York Red Bulls 1 - 7 - , FC Cincinnati 1 - 8 Junior Moreno - FC Cincinnati - converts the penalty with a shot with right foot to the right corner. | |
| 106' | Penalty saved. Andrés Reyes - New York Red Bulls - shot with right foot saved in the right corner. | |
| 106' | Penalty Shootout ends, New York Red Bulls 1 - 7 - , FC Cincinnati 1 - 8 | |
| Thats all. Game finished - New York Red Bulls 1 - 7 - , FC Cincinnati 1 - 8 |
ISOCountry Code:
Matched Country Groups:
