SM
| Venue: Yankee Stadium |
New York City FC | ||
| G | 1 | Luis Barraza |
| D | 80 | Justin Haak |
| D | 6 | James Sands |
| D | 93 | Tony Alfaro |
| M | 35 | Mitja Ilenič |
| M | 7 | Alfredo Morales |
| M | 55 | Keaton Parks |
| M | 3 | Brian Cufré |
| A | 10 | Santiago Rodríguez |
| A | 11 | Gabriel Pereira |
| A | 43 | Talles Magno |
Columbus Crew | ||
| G | 28 | Patrick Schulte |
| D | 25 | Sean Zawadzki |
| D | 31 | Steven Moreira |
| D | 18 | Malte Amundsen |
| M | 23 | Mohamed Farsi |
| M | 6 | Darlington Nagbe |
| M | 8 | Aidan Morris |
| M | 14 | Yaw Yeboah |
| A | 17 | Christian Ramirez |
| A | 20 | Alexandru Mățan |
| A | 9 | Cucho Hernández |
ISOCountry Code:
Matched Country Groups:
