SM
| Venue: Yankee Stadium |
New York City FC | ||
| G | 1 | Sean Johnson |
| CD-L | 6 | Alexander Callens |
| CD-R | 4 | Maxime Chanot |
| LB | 2 | Ben Sweat |
| RB | 13 | Saad Abdul-Salaam |
| AM | 10 | Maximiliano Morález S  |
| LM | 30 | Yangel Herrera |
| RM | 8 | Alexander Ring |
| F | 29 | Ismael Tajouri-Shradi |
| AM-L | 23 | Rodney Wallace |
| AM-R | 19 | Jesús Medina |
| Sub | 14 | Kwame Awuah |
| Sub | 41 | Brad Stuver |
| Sub | 12 | Ebenezer Ofori |
| Sub | 33 | Sebastien Ibeagha |
| Sub | 17 | Jonathan Lewis |
Orlando City | ||
| G | 1 | Joe Bendik |
| CD-L | 3 | Amro Tarek |
| CD-R | 2 | Jonathan Spector S |
| LB | 13 | Mohamed El-Monir |
| RB | 27 | RJ Allen S |
| M | 9 | Justin Meram |
| CM | 7 | Cristian Higuita S |
| AM | 16 | Sacha Kljestan |
| LM | 4 | Will Johnson |
| RM | 19 | Yoshimar Yotún |
| CF-R | 17 | Christopher Mueller |
| Sub | 22 | Lamine Sané |
| Sub | 10 | Josue Colman |
| Sub | 6 | Richie Laryea |
| Sub | 21 | Scott Sutter |
| Sub | 33 | Jose Villarreal |
| Sub | 36 | Earl Edwards |
| Sub | 15 | Cam Lindley |
ISOCountry Code:
Matched Country Groups:
