SM
| Venue: Red Bull Arena, Harrison |
New York Red Bulls | ||
| G | 1 | Carlos Miguel |
| D | 15 | Sean Nealis |
| D | 47 | John Tolkin |
| D | 4 | Andres Reyes |
| D | 12 | Dylan Nealis |
| M | 21 | Omir Fernandez |
| M | 23 | Cristian Cásseres Jr. |
| M | 16 | Dru Yearwood |
| M | 75 | Daniel Edelman |
| A | 74 | Tom Barlow |
| M | 17 | Cameron Harper |
New York City FC | ||
| G | 1 | Luis Barraza |
| D | 4 | Maxime Chanot |
| D | 13 | Thiago Martins |
| M | 24 | Tayvon Gray |
| M | 55 | Keaton Parks |
| M | 10 | Santiago Rodríguez |
| D | 6 | James Sands |
| A | 20 | Richard Ledezma |
| A | 11 | Gabriel Pereira |
| M | 22 | Kevin O'Toole |
| A | 43 | Talles Magno |
ISOCountry Code:
Matched Country Groups:
