S
SEARCH
M
SW
Jan 7, 2020 at 8pm UK
Man UtdManchester United
1-3
Man CityManchester City
Rashford (70')
FT(HT: 0-3)
Silva (17'), Mahrez (33'), Pereira (38' og.)

Combined XI: Manchester United vs. Manchester City

:Headline: Combined XI: Manchester United vs. Manchester City: ID:385222: from db_amp
Ahead of Tuesday night's EFL Cup semi-final first leg between Manchester United and Manchester City, Sports Mole selects its strongest combined XI from both squads.

Local rivals Manchester United and Manchester City will do battle for a place in the final of the EFL Cup having been drawn together in the last four, with the first leg taking place at Old Trafford on Tuesday night.

The derby comes exactly one month on from the last meeting between the two sides, when United upset the odds to beat City at the Etihad Stadium.

Man City once again go into this match as favourites having lifted the trophy in both of the last two seasons, with United the last team to beat them in this competition more than three years ago.

Here, Sports Mole selects its strongest combined XI from both squads, using only the players available for Tuesday's showdown.



The irony of the goalkeeping choice in this XI is that the two frontrunners - David de Gea and Ederson - are both unlikely to play, with Sergio Romero and Claudio Bravo expected to keep the gloves after the FA Cup outings at the weekend. Of those available, though, Ederson is top of the pile and, given that he is expected to have overcome an illness to be in contention to feature, he gets the nod between the sticks for us.

It is understandably a very Man City-heavy team, although a few more United players were close to getting in, including Aaron Wan-Bissaka, who has been one of his side's most consistent performers despite the team as a whole being wildly inconsistent. Kyle Walker just pips him and teammate Joao Cancelo to the right-back spot, though.

The opposite flank is arguably the weakest area for both teams, with regular changes at left-back throughout the campaign. Benjamin Mendy in full flow is a more potent attacking weapon than any of the others available, and that earns him a place ahead of Oleksandr Zinchenko, Angelino, Luke Shaw and Brandon Williams.

City have also had problems at centre-back this season, leading to Fernandinho playing most of the campaign in an unfamiliar role. The Brazilian has established himself as Pep Guardiola's first-choice central defender ahead of Nicolas Otamendi and John Stones, though, and also beats his clubmates to a place in this team.

The inconsistent selection of Otamendi and Stones means that the second centre-back role has to go to Harry Maguire, who has not exactly set the world alight since his record-breaking move from Leicester City but has, like Wan-Bissaka, been a consistent performer for the Red Devils this season.

With Paul Pogba and Scott McTominay among United's injury absentees it is an easy decision to choose an all-Man City midfield three, although it says a lot for Fred's improvement that he is also worthy of an honourable mention now.

However, the main question is which Man City three to choose, with the likes of Ilkay Gundogan and Bernardo Silva both unfortunate to miss out. Kevin De Bruyne is a sure-fire inclusion having registered 12 assists and seven goals in the Premier League this season, while in terms of holding midfielders Rodri is the best available considering Fernandinho is in a deeper role.

It was a very close choice between the two Silvas, but ultimately David Silva gets the nod in midfield due to his greater experience and ability to run a game. Both have directly contributed to the same number of goals this season, but Man City have struggled more when David Silva has been missing, which indicates just how important he remains to the team.

Marcus Rashford is the second United representative in this XI, having scored 12 goals and created four more in the league this season - a tally only De Bruyne can beat from these two squads. The England man shone when these two sides met at the Etihad a month ago, which also did him no harm when beating Riyad Mahrez to a place in the team.

Rashford on the left means that Raheem Sterling moves across to the right, and he is not far behind his compatriot's tally having scored 11 and assisted one this term.

Sterling's greatest competition for a place in this team came from within his own club, and the same is true of Sergio Aguero, who holds off competition from Gabriel Jesus despite the Brazilian's recent purple patch in front of goal. Anthony Martial, who is an illness doubt for this game, also deserves a mention, but despite only just coming back from injury it is Aguero who remains top of that particular pecking order.

amp_article__385222 : Database Data restored...  : 
last updated article - 2020-01-06 16:32:31:
html db last update - 2021-03-07 01:51:54 :

ex - 7200 : read : read cache amp html
Read more!
Share this article now:
Premier League Table
TeamPWDLFAGDPTS
CManchester CityMan City38275683325186
2Manchester UnitedMan Utd382111673442974
3Liverpool38209968422669
4Chelsea381910958362267
5Leicester CityLeicester382061268501866
6West Ham UnitedWest Ham381981162471565
7Tottenham HotspurSpurs381881268452362
8Arsenal381871355391661
9Leeds UnitedLeeds38185156254859
10Everton38178134748-159
11Aston Villa38167155546955
12Newcastle UnitedNewcastle38129174662-1645
13Wolverhampton WanderersWolves38129173652-1645
14Crystal Palace38128184166-2544
15Southampton38127194768-2143
16Brighton & Hove AlbionBrighton38914154046-641
17Burnley38109193355-2239
RFulham38513202753-2628
RWest Bromwich AlbionWest Brom38511223576-4126
RSheffield UnitedSheff Utd3872292063-4323
Scroll for more - Tap for full version

Subscribe to our Newsletter


Transfer Talk Daily
Match previews - twice weekly
Morning Briefing (7am UTC)
UC
Get the latest transfer news, match previews and news direct to your inbox!

Loading ...

Failed to load data.

Bundesliga Table
TeamPWDLFAGDPTS
CBayern MunichBayern34246499445578
2RB Leipzig34198760322865
3Borussia DortmundDortmund342041075462964
4Wolfsburg341710761372461
5Eintracht FrankfurtFrankfurt341612669531660
6Bayer LeverkusenB. Leverkusen3414101053391452
7Union BerlinUnion Berlin34121485043750
8Borussia MonchengladbachBorussia M'bach341310116456849
9Stuttgart34129135655145
10Freiburg34129135252045
11Hoffenheim341110135254-243
12Mainz 0534109153956-1739
13Augsburg34106183654-1836
14Hertha Berlin34811154152-1135
15Arminia Bielefeld3498172652-2635
16FC Koln3489173460-2633
RWerder Bremen34710173657-2131
RSchalke 04Schalke3437242586-6116
Scroll for more - Tap for full version
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
X

We value your privacy

A part of our GDPR compliance we need to ask for your consent. We and our partners use technology such as cookies on Sports Mole to personalise content and ads, provide social media features, and analyse our traffic. Click below to consent to the use of this technology on Sports Mole.